'Tentative' Unity - Now "Third Front" parties find a reason to unite

With Congress already in the back-foot (2G scam) and BJP not able to decide on the trade-off between controlling corruption in Karnataka Govt or holding on to power, the smaller parties are 'tentatively' uniting and raising their voice against corruption.

This 'front' mainly consists of Left parties (ex UPA 1 partner), JD(S) (trying best to take advantage of any political platform for political gains in Karnataka), TDP (another round of TDP Vs Congress), AIADMK (will do everything to ensure DMK is at the back-foot), BJD and RLD (both of these have their own 'strategic' reasons).

But before we expect too much from them, how long can they stay united is the challenge. Even earlier they have come together, only to leave apart with bitter differences.

The silver-lining is - because of this, the Congress and even the BJP would need to do further introspection. Unless Congress and BJP make tangible changes, they would continue to loss ground and respect from common man.

Political transformation always happens from within. May be, it's time for these parties to deeply introspect on their party structure, elevate younger leaders (with clean records) and come out with revitalized party policies. 

CWG dirt - A case to revamp the way we look at Sports Administration

Former Commonwealth Games (CWG) Organizing Committee (OC) officials T S Darbari and Sanjay Mahendroo who are close aides of Suresh Kalmadi, were arrested last Monday in a case pertaining to payments made to AM films and AM car hire, both owned by Ashish Patel, a UK based businessman. They were sent to CBI’s custody till November 22, 2010.  Another top Commonwealth Games official, M Jeychandren, who was Joint Director-General of finance and accounts (and was part of the empowered committee that finalized the controversial deal with London-based AM Films), was also later arrested for his alleged role in the Queen's Baton Relay scam.  Another official - Sudhir Verma, Deputy Director General (communication) of the Games Organizing Committee (also part of the empowered panel that picked AM Films to install video screens at the venue at exorbitant rates) is also being questioned by CBI.

But the most “important” person missing in action is – our dear Mr. Kalmadi. While there have been news that he is abroad, the way this ‘mess’ has been spilled wide open, it only provides a case to re-look at our entire mechanism of sports administration.

Commonwealth Games mess has provided an opportunity of sorts. It brings reason that these administrative boards/ associations need to be regulated and revamped. This should go across the games like Cricket etc. It is so unfortunate that these associations are usually run by either politicians or “administrators” who have never represented India in any match of international repute.

This brings down to – what is the role of Sports Ministry? Also, do we want to take sports like just any another thing in this country; or do we truly believe that if countries like US, China, Australia and the likes can do so well, why can’t we?

I haven’t come across a standard, publicized, yearly program on Athletics, Shooting, Swimming etc. Yes, there are once in a while events (like CWG), when we all sit-up and take notice, but other than that, there is total lack of co-ordinated approach to sports.

With close to 1.2 billion people, we can certainly don’t better!

Indeed, firstly, all Boards should be run only and only by ex-sportsmen of that sport. It should be transparent and all financial records should be published Quarterly. It cannot be something like BCCI, where a Board member even owns an IPL team and we don’t dare to call it conflict of interest?

These Boards should be given autonomy, however, under total supervision of Sports Ministry. Every state should have a world class stadium and every district (or a group of few) should have a “national” level stadium. All sports-persons should be graded in their respective games and there should be a clear compensation policy. Any sports-person who can go to district level and above, should be given the best-in-class food, equipment and all medical assistance. Later, if he cannot continue sports due to health issues, don’t dump him mid-way. There should be clear retirement plans and pension scheme.





Respect and support is all that is required by all upcoming talent. It would be a tragedy if the Government cannot retrospect and make rampant changes, after thoughtful deliberations.

Also, it is very important to see who is appointed as the Sports Minister. I hate it when I see a Minister mis-behaving with a coach and going for a photo opportunity (anyone who would have seen games in the last 3 months would know what I am talking about….hint - Wresting). Such Ministers are shameless. One who cannot respect the coach of a sports-person can never understand the meaning of sport and what it stands for.

The Sports Minister, first should have and must have played sports at the International level. He should present a clear vision on how the entire sports development would happen in the country. He should elaborate clearly, the clear road map of all sports, starting from infrastructure and facility at the village level to national level. How would he go about ensuring that the talent gets the essential support, right from the begining. Eg. if the girls in a village have immense potential in say wresting, what can he do to ensure that within a week all necessary equipment and food is available to them. Few weeks back, I saw a news report showing how our talented youth is suffering from the basic needs.

Sports needs geniune encouragement and real/actual support (monetary support - also very important). If without much support (for most sports), our sports-men/women are getting medals, imaging what they can do if given a proper planned road map and continous support.

For a nation wining medals at a global stage is as key as getting a UNSC seat!

Practice what you preach!

Karnataka has always been known as the IT hub of India. However, the state has recently been in news, thanks to serious corruption issues in BJP led/ Yeddyurappa Govt.

It is not that his opposition is known to be the best example of being clean, instead, they (the opposition) have had a habit of trying the best to disrupt the political stability. However, in this issue, they all have a point as there are grave mistakes committed by the government.



Current Karnataka Chief Minister - Mr. Yeddyurappa

The main issue is that Yeddyurappa's family (mainly his two sons) were given plots of land in and around Bangalore that were acquired by the government for public projects. The Opposition (mainly Kumaraswamy) alleges that Yeddyurappa misused his office to benefit his sons who were the beneficiaries of a massive land scam.

Kumaraswamy, in the last few days, has been able to produce several documents to show how government land was de-notified in a matter of days and sold to Yeddyurappa's family. This has raised huge public ire and increases the trust deficit that people would now have on the government.



If BJP wants to present its picture as a clean party, it is actually missing the bus. Delaying a decision to clean up the state party would only go against BJP in the long run. However, the larger question would then be - who would replace Yeddyurappa. If Reddy brothers gain control, things would only accentuate for the worse.

There can be no short-cuts and quick fixes. BJP needs to get its act together to earn the lost trust. It needs serious re-structuring and bringing up "non-lobby" based MLAs forward; something that won't be easy.



But then, if a party dares to teach another one on morality and best practices, it should first get its own act together. Practice what you preach!

Audio Tapes scandal

Heard this news on the internet about the Nira Radia audio tape case. Even managed to hear few clips on youtube and read few transcripts on various websites.

The most shocking part is that these convesations that Nira is supposedly having is with no ordinary journalists, rather some of the most respected names who are guiding the content of some top channels/ newspapers.

If this (and the context) turns out to be true, I'll be shocked. It only unearths the biggest scam in making.

What do we do as Indians? Corrupt politicians and even more corrupt journalists?

All I can say that as any responsible reader, we should observe this much closely without prejudice and favoritism. People may be drawn to early conclusions and become judgemental. Let this be debated and the guilty be punished.

The journalists in question should take the initiative and call for a debate. If journalists have the right to question all, they deserve to be questioned too, if such serious allegations are directed on them. If they have right to go after everyone even in the faintest of suspicion, there should be prime time shows and front page headlines which should "report" these allegations. Using media clout and not letting this topic be debated in electronic media is bringing doubts on the names of the journalists (in the audio tape).

One who is true, need not fear, hence it is best to come out open and debate; and one who isn't clean, truth will anyway catch them!

2G Scam – Let’s do beyond reporting and instead enact a stringent LAW to punish any offenders of such scams

One of the most important characteristics that a leader should have is Integrity. The importance of this quality would be core to a leader, especially if he is holding any public office and using tax payer’s money. One who doesn’t have this quality, doesn’t deserve to hold any government office.

The 2G scam has crossed benchmarks of being relentlessly greedy for personal objectives over duty-based obligations. It is not only an act of utter shamefulness, it only makes every fellow citizen even further away from trusting politicians. It is quite unfortunate to note that while politics as a subject is deep and for the benefit of the society, it has only got negative connotations, thanks to such politicians and scams.

But, while we debate on how this Rs 1.4 Lakh Crores (or so) scam happened in the first place, the questions and the consequences of this scam have far reaching implications.

I do not think anyone doubts the integrity of our Prime Minister. However, it is tragic to note that because of this notion of “coalition dharma”, such a corrupt Telecom Minister could make a fool of the system. 

Yes, if the PM would have intervened while noticing that the telecom minister was not following the rules and regulations properly, it may have costed him DMK’s ire and hence a risk to the Congress led government. However, not daring to stop a scam like this, to either save the government or because of total ignorance of such an act occurring, only raises eyebrows from the common man on street. There have been some news reports indicating that certain MPs had highlighted related issues to the PM, even 2 years back. This makes many bewildered that why even then no action was taken.

There is nothing more addictive and loathing than the greed of power, which is driven by money. If this scam comes out true, as shown by an impartial CAG report (the report - which we understand from the media), then there is a need to make a case out of this, so much that no other politician dares to do something like this again.

I and many an average Indian would demand a fair enquiry. But, it is high time that there is a need for a strict Law that punishes such offenders. If POTA, TADA and the likes have existed in India, there is no other more important law needed in India than one that states accountability of our Ministers and politicians.

RTI has bought a revolution. It only needs to be taken to the next step – ACCOUNTABILITY.

There should be a strict anti-corruption law, under which all politicians and people holding a government office should be covered. And yes, I am not talking about just a regular bill which gets enacted, but something which is far more decisive and lays down a transparent process to enable a fast final judgement. The act should have provisions of severe punishment (not just few years of jail).

There should be a specific branch under Judiciary, at the highest level, which should look only at such cases. The process should be fast (not more than 3 months in normal issues and 6 months in complex issues) and if the Minister/ politician/ public servant is found guilty, punishment should be no less than ensuring that the person regrets cheating the nation and its people. Additionally, we should have an independent arm of investigation (and not CBI), which doesn’t come under the government and is independent (like CAG). This investigation arm should table a report in each session of the Parliament, highlighting the status of all issues of corruption against current and past parliamentarians.

Anti-corruption and vigilance agencies need to be re-modeled/ energized. Specific objectives should be laid and the officials running these agencies should be answerable to the public at large. Bi-annual media briefings should be given to the press to highlight the status of key corruption cases.

Lastly, the whistle-blower policy should be clear, strengthened and transparent. One who highlights the issue should not be harassed and the system should ensure that enough encouragement is provided to officials who are honest and ethical.

Let us be heard and let this be debated!

India lost $ 462 bn in illegal capital flows as per a report by Global Financial Integrity

We may recall that few months back a lot of talk happened on huge piles of illicit money being parked in some European banks. Infact, this subject got raised even during the last parliamentary elections.

A latest report by an international watchdog - Global Financial Integrity has estimated the amount of black money. The report estimates that between 1948 to 2008 the tax evasion, crime, and corruption have removed gross illicit assets from India worth US $462 billion (i.e. more than 20 Lakh crores!). This amount is nearly 40% of India's GDP.

Some of the primary findings of the report:

• From 1948 through 2008, India lost a total of US $213 billion in illicit financial flows (or illegal capital flight).  These illicit financial flows were generally the product of: tax evasion, corruption, bribery and kickbacks, and criminal activities.
• Adjusted Estimates: The present value of India’s total illicit financial flows (IFFs) is at least US $462 billion. This is based on the short-term U.S. Treasury bill rate as a proxy for the rate of return on assets.
• India’s aggregate illicit flows are more than twice the current external debt of US $230 billion.
• Based on the last five years of the study, 2004-2008, India lost assets at a rate of US $19 billion per year.
• Total capital flight out of India represents approximately 16.6 percent of India’s GDP as of year-end 2008. In present value terms, India lost an equivalent of about 36 percent of its 2008 GDP which represents a staggering loss of capital.
• Some 68 percent of India’s aggregate illicit capital loss occurred after India’s economic reforms in 1991, indicating that deregulation and trade liberalization actually contributed to/accelerated the transfer of illicit money abroad.

The report is authored by Dev Kar, formerly a Senior Economist at the International Monetary Fund (IMF), is Lead Economist at Global Financial Integrity (GFI) at the Center for International Policy.

This brings down some hard questions - what is the Government doing to get portion of this money back. Have they identified top 10 individuals that hold such huge cash offshore; if so, they should make these names public and discuss this in Parliament. It is quite a possibility that even this staggering amount may fall short of the actual illicit money parked by some of our rich politicians which may have happened via cash transfers etc.

The Govt. should pursue the objective of ensuring that this money is bought back. The Govt. should have a debate on this topic in the Parliament and subsequently raise this at U.N

The Govt. should begin this cleaning process by first releasing the data on such illicit money of politicians held abroad.